Is "Indie" a Bogus Concept in 2014?

Categories: Music Bidness

Photo by Amanda Rhoades/Flickr Commons
Indie, or not Indie? That is the question
Recently Joe Steinhardt took a moment to ponder the year that had just passed, and didn't like what he saw.

Steinhardt runs one of my favorite music labels, Don Giovanni Records. His New Jersey-based outfit was built, as he tells it, to promote the music his friends made. His label is now blessed with loads of talent, from sweet-voiced singer-songwriter Laura Stevenson -- who will be at Fitzgerald's next month with Against Me! and Cheap Girls -- to the weirdly wonderful Jeffrey Lewis. Anyone who has read even a few of my bits knows I'm enamored of Screaming Females, one of the label's bands and arguably its best-known.

Despite that upside, Steinhardt was concerned. He felt 2013 was the year that independent music "broke," and expressed his worries in a polarizing blog for I decided to ask him about it and got a couple of other independent labels, including Houston's own Artificial Head Records, to weigh in on his thoughts.

"In my mind, I will always remember 2013 as the year I saw artists using 'self-release' and 'small label' as a marketing strategy," he wrote. "This year, I watched these truly subversive and independent ways of releasing music being used as stepping stones to majors and major indies, with a goal of building hype and mystery rather than as a mark of independence."

That's the crux of his complaint. Steinhardt feels some acts are bastardizing "indie" and "DIY" to gain some credibility. He declined to offer specific examples when asked; smart man. But, his viewpoint might best be exemplified by Macklemore, whose indie credibility has been questioned, particularly following his Grammy wins.

"There have always been users," says Alex DenBaars. "There have always been people who participated in underground music culture because it was convenient rather than because independence from an exploitative system of making art mattered to them."

Photo courtesy of Goathead Record Collective
GRC artists
DenBaars is more a spokesman than a label owner. And the group he speaks for, New Mexico-based Goathead Record Collective, is more a collective than a label. He falls in line with the purist argument in Steinhardt's message.

"Right now, even in my circles, there are pretenders," he says. "There are people who would join the ranks of the very same organizations that have been holding us back our entire lives. They looked at DIY culture and saw a group they could exploit and use to eventually get that MasterCard sponsorship they always secretly wanted."

At home, the founders of Artificial Head Records take a less ideological view.

"Joe states, 'Being independent means something. Independent journalists, artists, musicians, promoters, and labels should either be supporting each other, or what's the point?' says Artificial Head's Paul Chavez. "Well, the point is that bands, labels, writers...many of them aspire to one day 'make it big' and gain the respect and admiration of their family and friends so they can justify the years of toil for their rock and roll dreams."

"If we all lived in Joe's world, none of us ever grow beyond being independent and we would just kind of wallow around in this special hell of being righteous and ethical," he adds. "That may be fine for some, but not everyone dreams the same way."

Story continues on the next page.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
Fabricio Ycaza
Fabricio Ycaza

I think that indie can only mean independent. If your act is part of a major/small label and you no longer manage your own outreach to your followers then I do not believe the tag applies. I am personally not fond of acts calling themselves indie as a genre, I rather use it myself to describe my perception of their work. If a major/small labels uses "indie tactics" they are not an "indie label" which I think is part of what frustrates Steinhardt. Macklemore is no longer indie, he is now mainstream which is most musicians goal.

Now Trending

Houston Concert Tickets

From the Vault