Should We Love Music Made by Awful People?

Categories: Dig This

Photo by Matthew Keever
Recently I was walking through the grocery store, wearing headphones that blasted music, and I saw something that disturbed me. It was a young male, who couldn't have been any older than I am, wearing long hair and jeans like any good metalhead should. But what I saw across his chest on his black band shirt disturbed me. It was the logo for the band As I Lay Dying.

As you may or may not know, As I Lay Dying's front man Tim Lambesis was arrested on charges of solicitation to commit murder earlier this year after allegedly attempting to hire an undercover police officer to murder his wife. I was disgusted personally, and I couldn't see how this guy could possibly continue to wear an As I Lay Dying shirt, supporting Lambesis and his alleged actions by proxy.

Then I realized to whom I was listening at that very moment: Michael Jackson.

Twice in his life was Michael Jackson accused of child molestation; once in 1993, and again in 2003. The first time the investigation was determined inconclusive. The second time, he was charged, went to trial, and was acquitted on all counts. I remember the second trial and its public fiasco pretty well. I also remember how the public and the media made a judgment on it almost two years before a jury did.

I'll never forget my mom's reaction at least, which was to severely and harshly damn Jackson with little regard for due process. She decided his music was dead to her, and he himself was a sick pervert not worth being allowed to live in the United States of America. She made up her mind, along with many others, long before Jackson had a chance to fight it out in a court of law.

Personally though, I never much cared. I still listened to Jackson's music. I still listen to it today, and it never registered in my mind that the charges against him should affect my enjoyment of his music in any way. After all, his music has nothing to do with what he does in a bedroom, does it?

But it raises an interesting point: can we separate the artist from his or her work?

My mom would have argued that you can't. Historical evidence would have a different say on the matter though. Take the compositions of Richard Wagner for example.

Wagner was a vehement anti-Semite. Anti-Semitism exists throughout his works, which were favorites of Adolf Hitler, who readily appropriated them for his Nazi agenda. As a Jew, I shudder at the thought of how Wagner was played over concentration-camp loudspeakers for all those suffering to hear.

But history has not damned Wagner for his views or the ways in which his work was put to use. Instead, he is still revered as a wonderful composer who revolutionized opera for the 20th century. The contrast between Wagner's reputation as a composer and as an anti-Semite has even been played for jokes on shows like Curb Your Enthusiam, but few would legitimately attempt to argue that his contributions as an artist were insignificant because of his beliefs.

History has a few other examples we can find of this as well, on even smaller scales. While it may be impossible to deny Wagner's influence, fewer would label Gary Glitter as one of the great artists of our time. Nevertheless, Glitter, who was convicted in Vietnam of sexual acts with underage girls as well as possession of child pornography in his native England, still enjoys a reasonably decent reputation as a musician despite his crimes.

It's certainly never stopped a DJ from playing "Rock and Roll Part 2" at basketball games.

Story continues on the next page.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
Hans Gruber Mellencamp
Hans Gruber Mellencamp

Nothing wrong with buying/selling drugs, As I Lay Dying's music blows. Thats why you shouldn like them.


Excellent introspective mea culpa.  HP needs more of this.

Jeffrey Aiello
Jeffrey Aiello

People still go see Michael Vick play on Sundays.... and who know what heinous acts go on by NFL/NBA/MLB players each and every day that we don't hear about or where they aren't caught? Drunk driving, buying and selling drugs, and on and on... food for thought.

Now Trending

Houston Concert Tickets

From the Vault