Why Has the Strokes' Comeback Tanked?

Categories: Music Bidness

The Strokes Craig Hlavaty.jpg
Photo by Craig Hlavaty
The great hope of rock and roll critics at the start of the 21st century, the Strokes, released their newest record Comedown Machine last month. It was met with the sort of lukewarm reviews that the band has been receiving for years now; about the greatest compliment anyone can give it is that "it's better than their last one."

What went wrong? Prior to their break from releasing albums between the years 2006 and 2011, the band had been critical darlings and the hippest band to like since Pavement hit the airwaves. This was the band everyone had been waiting for to prevent the death of rock at the hands of R&B and hip-hop. So what the hell happened?

Well, to begin with, let's look at the band's earliest days. Coming out of New York City, the Strokes were a breath of fresh air in the post-Britpop landscape of indie-rock. They had a laid-back rock sound that evoked the best of David Bowie and Iggy Pop's late-'70s work and sounded like a band fresh out of the garage making noises that teenagers could actually hum along to. No cheese, none of the garbage nu-metal trappings of radio rock of the time, and no pretension.

They came on with a sound that today is commonplace, but at the time was a revolution. It was a rejection of everything that had made mainstream rock overwrought, clichéd, and annoying after Nirvana, while also being catchy and vital enough to overcome people's aversions to the weirdness and rawness of prior indie-rock. It didn't hurt either that the members were sexy and hip, when most indie-rock musicians up that point had been weird music nerds who had neither the desire nor the capability to be sexy or hip.

IsThisIt 0419.jpg
They were also rocking at a time when rock's other greatest hope, Radiohead, had all but abandoned guitar-driven rock and roll music. If the biggest band in the world at the time had said "we've had enough of guitars," that meant something, but the Strokes came out unafraid to play squeally, guitar-driven rock, even while possessing some of the same root sounds as Radiohead, with their staccato bass lines and stiff, mechanical drumming.

Is This It? paved the way for bands like Modest Mouse, Franz Ferdinand, Spoon, the Yeah Yeah Yeahs, and Phoenix to top the charts and get their songs in movies, TV shows, and advertisements when no one could have ever guessed in the previous decade that bands like those would go anywhere but into the headphones of a record-store clerk.

In effect, a band like Arcade Fire could never have taken home Album of the Year at the Grammys if people hadn't been introduced to the Strokes first.

With an album like Is This It? to ignite their fanbase, the Strokes could coast for a while purely on that. And they did. Let's be honest here, if we're discussing how vital Is This It? was to the indie-rock revolution of the past decade, we have to admit that follow-up Room on Fire did little more than toe the party line. Which is okay, because that's a common thing for sophomore records to do. It's nothing surprising, and there's nothing wrong with it really.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

"Recently, The Strokes and MGMT - with dimensions and sensitivities - succeeded. Julian has a punk rock side, a super strong emotional impact in its melodies. It was important to have this album to feel surrounded by our contemporaries."-Daft Punk (Also please note this was never a comeback, Angles was released in 2011)


I just don't think people understand this new groove they're on. I don't think the Is This it folk know how to listen to Comedown Machine.  You're playing a losing game looking for that old shit.

You gotta break away from their debut.  Inside the packaging of this new album are the same photos that are in the Is This It packaging, except the faces are blacked out.  That says a lot!

To work with the Author's car reference, yes, they are in a different car, but please believe that they are moving.. you just can't see them because they're on a different road. 

I hope to find a review of Comedown Machine that does not resort to the stale retelling of their history, but instead breaks down musically, in depth, what they are doing. I'm hearing new levels of funk and groove from them.  Whether or not this album is as innovative as Is This it, I don't know. But they are on this album doing things that no other "rock" bands are doing right now. They show some good range, and maybe perfection will come with later efforts. Or maybe "perfecting the sound" is not even the aim. 


Ouch, but you said what my heart couldn't.

This new album is boring and the songs independently lack fluidity. Mehhh :(

Now Trending

Houston Concert Tickets

From the Vault