Tony Dungy, Michael Sam and the Complicated Relationship Between Sports, Faith and Rights

Photo by Marcus Qwertyus
Former coach Tony Dungy thinks Michael Sam will be a distraction.
Former coach and all around good guy Tony Dungy said he would not have drafted Michael Sam, the All-American linebacker taken by the St. Louis Rams who is openly gay.In and interview with the Tampa Tribune, Dungy explained he believes Sam's sexual orientation will be a distraction, "Not because I don't believe Michael Sam should have a chance to play, but I wouldn't want to deal with all of it. It's not going to be totally smooth...things will happen."

As some have pointed out, Dungy has been a fervent advocate of players like Michael Vick and Tim Tebow, both players who have caused massive distractions -- Vick for his jail time after his involvement with a dog fighting ring and Tebow for his outspoken views on Christianity combined with his natural charisma as a Heisman Trophy winner. The former coach has also been behind the move to provide equal opportunity for African American coaches who have historically been under represented in the NFL.

Some might call this hypocrisy, but a more apt descriptor might be "complicated."

Dungy, who is black, has undoubtedly been forced to confront racism throughout his life. He has been open in his belief that the NFL should do better at including blacks in the hiring process, even writing the foreward for the book Equal Coaching Opportunity in the NFL. So, how does his concern over the distraction an openly gay player might bring to the locker room not make him a hypocrite? Namely, his faith.

Dungy is a Christian. It is not surprising that a man with his beliefs would find Sam's orientation difficult or even objectionable. And despite his strong stance on equal opportunity for those who may have been discriminated against, religion has a way of throwing a monkey wrench in to the machinery of logic. And, in some ways, being black may make it even more difficult.

It is not uncommon for African Americans who also have strong religious convictions to be offended by the notion that gay rights and equal rights are the same them because they don't believe homosexuals were born gay. They, on the other hand, had no choice when it came to their race. It's a razor thin line in the sand, but one that has driven a wedge between evangelical and non-religious Democrats/liberals who typically stand on the same side of most socio-political issues. Those who would walk lockstep in protest of any other form of social injustice find themselves at odds over this one.

I suspect Dungy finds himself in the same confounding space. And while he has been careful in the words he chose to describe his concerns, it is hard to believe someone so adamant in his defense of other players who have created massive distractions through their sometimes troubling actions would suddenly decide being gay was simply too much unless his faith was a factor...and his football.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
Ivan Jimenez
Ivan Jimenez

Nobody had a problem with teams and coaches saying, 'I don't want to mess with this Tebow thing! No way, Dude.'" And what was Tebow? He was a devout Christian. He leads with his Christianity. And that's what they were saying: 'I don't want this circus! I don't want this mess.

conebaby topcommenter

I'm torn on this. I used to like Dungy, til the 2007 thing in Indiana. And when Collins (NBA) came out, he tweeted that he didn't "agree with his lifestyle" but that he deserved respect, and the same opportunities as anyone else. And whether Dungy "agrees" with the "lifestyle" (its. not. a. lifestyle.), for someone who apologized/advocated for VICK and all the distractions that came with, it's too much hypocrisy for this former fan. I love dogs, and The Gheys, so maybe it's just easier for me to be consistent.


He was a mediocre quarterback who was too slow. I can't believe that anyone still thinks his career fizzled out because of his ostentatious display of religions.

Now Trending

Houston Concert Tickets

From the Vault