Rally to Kill One Bin for All

Categories: Environment

The recycling fight comes to the steps of Houston's city hall today when labor and environmental justice group representatives (along with Miss Houston Rodeo Jacquelyn Young) partake in a rally they hope will convince the city to trash its "One Bin for All" recycling initiative.

The protesters are against the plan for a number of reasons including loss of city jobs and revenue, air pollution in poor communities of color, and well, it just doesn't seem right to mix a poopy diaper with a good recyclable juice carton.

Single-stream recycling, which is when all your plastic and paper stuff gets mixed into separate containers, and curb-side pickup isn't really the way things are moving in Houston. "The city claims that Houston doesn't care about recycling." said Melanie Scruggs of the Texas Campaign for the Environment.

"We're opposing this because it privatizes city contracts; if this proposal goes through, people would lose their benefits," she said.

As we mentioned in June, the city got hold of a grant to do the one-bin thing that makes throwing out your garbage easier, while the good stuff is sorted from the trash trash.

Back in March, Mayor Annise Parker announced that the city had received a $1 million grant as finalists for a proposed recycling project, "One Bin for All." New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg, the sponsor of the contest, was, of course, a big fan of the idea, which would take recycling out of the hands of individuals and make it something that simply happened to all Houston trash as a matter of course.

Several of the protesters are planning to address city council at this afternoon's meeting. They'll get another boost of attention when ABC13 airs an investigation on recycling facilities and their pollution factor, Scruggs said.

"We wanted to have this rally to show the mayor and the city council that this doesn't have any support. What the city needs to do is get a long-term plan" she said.

So is Houston behind the times when it comes to a serious recycling program? Most would say yes.

"The city has been lagging behind all the cities to the east of I-35 that have curb-side recycling like Corpus Christi, Texarkana and San Marcos," said Robin Schneider, executive director of Texas Campaign for the Environment.

Still, single-stream recycling may not be the the final answer to all our recycling concerns, as some studies point out.

We'll see if city hall moves ahead with the one-bin deal (which we're pretty sure it will), or what other alternatives present themselves.

The recycling rally is today at 12:30 p.m. on the steps of Houston City Hall.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

If everyone does their own part in pre sorting and gets penalized for not following the law accordingly, use fines to finance more recycling projects/upgrades.It would be more organized and have a better chance of knowing it actually gets sorted. Sounds like potential for tax increase. Difficult solution for an easy problem.


The one bin for all concept has evolved because Houston apparently is not yet serious about recycling and part of that blame belongs to Mayor Parker.

This TMBTARR "technology" has been tried and has barely diverted more than Houston’s current patchwork of underfinanced, inconsistent and otherwise beleaguered recycling does today.

As with cycling, Houston is making great strides (w/private money & public support involved) but, w/o having safe streets to reach these parks it's not a complete or safe program. 

The same can be said about recycling, the single stream program should have been rolled out years ago.  More unattended local drop off sites should be opening in more locations to compliment curbside service rather than sites being closed. 

Most importantly, the state of Texas needs to institute a container deposit program along the lines of California's very successful CRV. 


The study linked here advocates for dual stream recycling over single-stream recycling, which means more sorting, not less.


Texas Campaign for the Environment needs to go back and look at THEIR history with the City of Houston on this issue.


No comments to date?  It looks like Houston has little time for recycling.  That One Bin proposal should do well there.  

Now Trending

Houston Concert Tickets

From the Vault