Why Schaub's Latest Blunder Is His Brad Lidge Moment In Houston

Categories: Sports

Photo by Marco Torres
Gary Kubiak's play call wasn't the reason for Matt Schaub's latest interception.
The beauty and tragedy of sports comes in transcendent, "Where were you?" moments.

I remember the apartment and spot on the couch in December 2011 where I watched T.J. Yates find Kevin Walter for an improbable last-second touchdown in Cincinnati, clinching the Texans' first playoff berth. On a trip to my childhood home, jaws dropped to the floor in front of my old TV during Tracy McGrady's "13 in 35" miracle to beat the Spurs.

On the other side, I recall frozen stares at an Astros' party after Albert Pujols blasted a game-winning, 3-run homer off Brad Lidge in Game 5 of the 2005 NLCS, when the Astros were one out away from their first-ever World Series. We barely moved or spoke for the next hour amid an almost-paralyzing state of shock. I still cringe entering Velvet Melvin Pub on Richmond, because that's where I watched my beloved Missouri Tigers lose to No. 15 seed Norfolk State in the NCAA hoops tournament back in March 2012.

Guess which category Matt Schaub's latest "pick 6" falls into?

The scene from Sunday

I've spent large chunks of the past 10 years around professional athletes. The scene in Reliant Stadium's home locker room after Sunday's game was among the most depressing I've witnessed. Frustration. Anger. Hurt.

Above all? Silence.

This wasn't just any game. This was a statement game. After losing embarrassingly in Baltimore, largely due to a game-changing "pick 6" from Schaub, players said the sense of urgency was at an all-time high. For most of Sunday, they played like it.

Marco Torres, Houston Press
Ben Tate's fumble was costly.
Seattle might be the best team in the NFL, and the Texans dominated them on both sides. They outgained the Seahawks by more than 200 yards and controlled both lines of scrimmage. Even after an untimely Ben Tate fumble and losing Brian Cushing to a concussion, they were in ideal position to capture their most significant win since crushing the Ravens in Week 7 of the 2012 season.

Even if the Texans had punted the ball back to Seattle with a 20-13 lead and 2:30 left, the odds of the Seahawks marching 90 yards for a tying touchdown in that timeframe were incredibly long.

Head coach Gary Kubiak blamed himself after the game for not running the ball on 3rd-and-4 from the Seattle 40-yard line. Hopefully he did that to spare Schaub's feelings, because the play call wasn't the issue. I loved that the Texans were aggressive and tried to seal the game on offense. It worked against Cincinnati in last year's playoffs when Schaub hit Garrett Graham for a game clincher, giving us an unforgettable Schaub celebration.

Unless you have the defense of the 2001 Ravens -- and possibly not even then -- an NFL team can't seriously contend for a Super Bowl with a game plan that hides its quarterback. They have to have trust in the quarterback's basic instincts to make some plays and avoid debilitating mistakes.

On Sunday's defining play, Schaub could have taken a sack. He also could have thrown the ball away. Instead, with a seven-point lead and a defense playing fantastic football, he did the one thing he couldn't do -- throw a ball up for grabs against a blanketed receiver. In an instant, all the fantastic work the Texans did for the first 57 minutes against one of the NFL's elite teams was rendered meaningless.

This was one of those moments, and Schaub knew it. That's why he stayed on the ground, head in hands, for what felt like an eternity. It was atypical for Schaub, who has bounced back many times before. Two weeks earlier, he led game-tying and game-winning touchdown drives in the closing minutes of regulation and overtime against Tennessee, mere minutes after throwing a dreaded "pick 6".

It wasn't happening Sunday. The Texans took the ball for three more series after the Richard Sherman touchdown, each time with the ability to end the game on a score. They never even crossed the Seattle 40. After being sacked just twice in the first 57 minutes, the shell-shocked version of Schaub we saw going forward went down twice in 10 minutes -- each crippling a drive that seemed to have momentum.

The Texans said what they had to say in the locker room about "trusting" Schaub. It's against unwritten NFL player code to throw a hard-working teammate under the bus, publicly. But we're already four games into the 16-game season. More than 20 percent of points allowed by the Texans have directly come off the right arm of Matt Schaub, now with a "pick 6" streak of three games. For the fifth time in the last six Texans games -- including the season-opening interception in San Diego and the "pick 6" in the AFC Wild Card game against Cincinnati -- momentum largely swung due to a Schaub turnover.

The trust in that room -- both within Schaub himself, and from fellow coaches and players -- is mostly gone, no matter what is said. Athletes have more perspective than fans, but they understand the gravity of these situations. Behind closed doors, the team's confidence in Schaub was already on thin ice following the playoff loss in January.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

The problem here is that Kubiak is trying to run the old Broncos offense with Bernie Kosar instead of John Elway.  Instead of an athlete, you have a slow, weakarmed player who panics in the pocket.  (No doubt from the injuries he's sustained in his career in Houston.  Gun shy QBs aren't that rare.)  Kubiak unfortunately gains nothing from Yates who has a stronger arm, but is about as accurate as Schaub at his worst.  Keenum showed all the signs of being a deer in the headlights kind of QB, so that's not going to help.  No, this won't be Houston's year, and the likely firing of Kubiak is unfortunately the opening for Bum Phillips to con McNair into promoting Wade into the head coaching job.  No help there...

Rocky Alvarado
Rocky Alvarado

Except Brad Lidge made his mistake in the championship series against a hated rival, and Schaub's was in an early regular season game.


I certainly don't want Schaub to fail. I'd love for him to prove me wrong with a great performance in San Francisco and ultimately in the playoffs. He's a great guy and I backed him for many years. 

I picked the Texans to reach the 2012 Super Bowl, led by Schaub, and didn't even list him as one of my "biggest questions". 

I also gave Matt a fairly rave review after the Texans signed him to a new contract (in September 2012):

You want facts? There's plenty in this piece, if you care enough to read. More than 20% of points allowed by the Texans this season have directly come off of Matt's arm. He's thrown a "pick 6" in three consecutive games, and had a game-changing turnover in 5 of 6. They didn't cross the Seattle 40 on any of the possessions following his meltdown, and he took two drive-killing sacks -- as many as he did in the other 57 minutes combined. This isn't what I want to happen, nor is it supposition and conjecture. It's just the reality.

As for what's going on in the locker room, I linked to reports in January of teammates not believing in him. By any objective measure, his performance has slipped even more to start 2013. It doesn't take being a professional athlete to put those things together and understand that there are concerns there. Moreover, Kubiak himself -- as I posted in the column -- said after the game that he should have run the ball on the fateful 3rd and 4. What do you think that reflects? Running plays on third downs of that distance are very rare in the NFL and have a low probability of success. The reason Gary is second-guessing himself over not calling a run is because he doesn't have confidence in his QB not to make a big mistake. 

I hope Matt turns it around, but the confidence issue -- both for himself and his fellow coaches and players -- is very real.


stop writing about what you WANT to happen, i.e. Schaub's failure, and give us some facts, instead of supposition and conjecture. you're not a professional athlete and you don't know what's going on in that locker room.

Joseph Robert Barry
Joseph Robert Barry

For the last time, Schaubs pick six, a big negative impact moment in sundays game, was only one repeat one moment that would lead to loss. I'm sick of everyone laying this on Schaub. Here is the actual loss breakdown. 1. Bad play calling in second half. 2.Tate fumble that led to field goal. 3. 90+ yards touchdown drive. 4. Schaubs pick six. Schaubs moment was in no way a Brad Lidge moment. It was a big impact moment but also one of several moments that impacted the game for a loss. It was a big moment but not the only moment. Schaub Kubiak Tate and the defense all get thrown under the bus for loss.

Brandy Wells
Brandy Wells

I remember when Lidge got us to the World Series then couldn't perform. He then went to the Phillies and won it for them. We just need to be patient. If not, put in Yates!


@BenDuBose Don't forget that before the start of the season, GM Smith said Schaub needed to "play better."  Translation, "Hey, I like my job!"

Now Trending

Houston Concert Tickets

From the Vault