The Case for T.J.: Why Yates Deserves to Be Texans' No. 2 QB

Categories: Sports

Marco Torres, Houston Press
It's an unpopular opinion, but T.J. Yates did enough this preseason to keep his job.
If or when Case Keenum is named the No. 3 quarterback for the Texans, it should be noted that he didn't lose the race to be Matt Schaub's top backup. T.J. Yates won it.

In a Chronicle poll Thursday night, 86% of fans wanted Keenum to be named No. 2. It's understandable, given his days at the University of Houston, and the spark he gave the Houston offense at times over the past month.

Indeed, Keenum's strong performance -- 43-of-63 (68 percent), 482 yards (7.7 average), three touchdowns, zero interceptions and 106.7 quarterback rating -- would usually be enough to win a job. In fact, two weeks ago, I wrote here that Keenum should win it, based on his improvisation skills and overall upside.

From that end, little has changed. The only problem is that Yates has been even better, and it's time to give him his due.

For Yates, the final preseason numbers are staggering. A 70-percent completion percentage (35-of-50), 417 total yards (8.3 average), four touchdowns and no interceptions -- all for a quarterback rating of 121.8. Despite his lack of mobility relative to Keenum, Yates was only sacked one time.

From a physical standpoint, the 6-foot-4 Yates is the better player. There's a reason he was drafted (2011 5th round) and the generously listed 6-foot-1 Keenum wasn't. Quite simply, Yates is taller and has a bigger arm. He also has the advantage of NFL experience -- and in December and January, at that.

The question comes down to whether Keenum's mental skills -- i.e., his creativity and improvisation -- are far enough beyond Yates's to override the disadvantages in size, arm and experience. Though Yates was impressive as a rookie (rating of 80.7, guiding the Texans to four wins in seven tries, including one in the playoffs), his limited second-year experiences weren't good, and many around the team wondered if Yates had the mental spark to be a legitimate NFL quarterback and not merely a system caretaker.

In short, could Yates be a playmaker?

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

Keenum is an underdog which Kubiak obviously likes.  (Sticking with the average Schaub all this time.)

Mark Markovich
Mark Markovich

Of the two, I would say that Keenum has better game awareness, but Yates has a much better arm. Keenum is going to have a much harder time in tight coverage against NFL (as opposed to camp fodder) DBs.

Amy McMullen
Amy McMullen

Case seems to hit the receiver better than Yates! Faster and can run when challenged!


finally, the voice of reason

the bottom line is that we have seen Yates win in the regular season and the playoffs. as much as this town wants to suck Keenum's dork, he's still unproven. given that he didn't out-perform Yates in the preseason, no reason he should vault to #2


@Papa_Kin @stevek77536 @aaronhernandez Good point.  Brees is the same size as Keenum, and a real winner.  But when you have two quarterbacks with very similar good performance, I'll go with the big guy.  Those blitzes can hurt.  (BTW, Matt Schaub: 6'5", 240lbs.  And also a winner.)

Now Trending

Houston Concert Tickets

From the Vault