Judge Kevin Fine's Rejection of Drug Search Warrant Gets Rejected

Categories: Courts, Crime

Appeals court thought the judge was being too nit-picky.
District Judge Kevin Fine has been a unique jurist since taking the bench after his 2008 election -- challenging Texas's enforcement of the death penalty, saying a woman couldn't have been raped because she was "on top" and tossing out a jury's murder conviction because the defense didn't call a possibly exonerating witness.

He's at it again: He threw out a search warrant in a crack case because it wasn't specific enough. That happens occasionally, even in prosecutor-loving Harris County, but an appeals court has firmly rejected Fine's ruling, saying the omissions were trivial.

The case involved an alleged Third Ward crack house busted last year.

To get a search warrant, a Houston police officer swore in an affidavit that a reliable informant told him drugs were being sold out of a house in the 4200 block of Eppes; the officer gave the informant money to go buy some.

The informant was out of the officer's sight for about two minutes, but came back with a rock of crack.

The informant told the officer he had stood at the front door, given the money and watched a man enter the house and get the drugs. The man then told the informant to come back later.

Endorsing objections by the defense, Fine ruled that the magistrate who signed the search warrant did not have sufficient evidence to believe there were more drugs to be found in the house.

Fine said the time the tip was received had not been specified, the officers lost sight of the informant so the buy was not "controlled," and just because the guy at the house said to come back didn't mean he was offering to sell more drugs to the informant.

The 14th Court of Appeals didn't take well to Fine's nit-picking.

"Considering all the facts in the affidavit along with reasonable inferences from those facts," the appellate panel ruled, "we conclude that there was a fair probability that additional illegal drugs continued to be stored and sold at the residence just as the original tip indicated."

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

God, I don't want another conservative (read bigot) like Jean Hughes on the bench but this MoMo's time's up.

Prof Topkat
Prof Topkat

Isn't it way past time to impeach this dipshit or have a recall election?  The bench is no place for a clown!

I've obtained many search warrants on similar information and never once were my affidavits successfully challenged. 

Jim C
Jim C

Is this guy's first name Kevin or Larry?


"The bench is no place for a clown!" In Texas? Really?

I've gone before judges making racist jokes and speak in "ethnic" slang, IN OPEN COURT. While co-counsel has told me to keep my mouth shut (or lose appointments/face sanctions) the prosecutors stood slack-jawed. That's just in the municiple courts. See my comment on Judge Hughes, below.

However, I do agree with the rest of your sentiments. This guy makes Larry Standley look competent.

Now Trending

Houston Concert Tickets

From the Vault