Defy Gravity: 9 Awesome Special Effects That Aren't CGI

Categories: Film and TV

I saw the trailer recently for the upcoming lost-in-space film Gravity, due out next weekend, and had to cringe. I mean, the story seems original enough -- spacewalkers suffer freak accident, become untethered and adrift in space with only themselves for survival. I have no idea how they're going to make an entire movie about that, but hey, Castaway worked. But what really bothered me was just how fake the special effects look. And this is why I can not stand CGI.

I get that, in order to appreciate movies from the get-go, viewers have to be willing to suspend even just a little bit of belief. Because movies are fantasy -- those things haven't really happened. But with the case of CGI, I just can't do it. I can't suspend my belief enough to get over just how shitty it looks. And the problem is often that the bigger the movie budget, the more unnecessary CGI is employed. Just compare the special effects in the original Star Wars movies to the prequels.

The trouble with technology is that it become obsolete SO QUICKLY. And some of my favorite movies have been made better by trying to solve the puzzle of how to make special effects that look truly realistic and believable without taking you out of the story. So I polled my fellow Art Attack writers for some of their favorite examples of movies with well-done, non-GCI special effects. Check out our list below.


The Ten Commandments

This one does look a little dated but come on -- it's one of the most storied special effects of all time. From IMDb:

The illusion of the Red Sea parting was achieved by large "dump tanks" that were flooded, then the film was shown in reverse. The two frothing walls of water were created by water dumped constantly into "catch basin areas" then the foaming, churning water was visually manipulated and used sideways for the walls of water. A gelatin substance was added to the water in the tanks to give it more of a sea water consistency.

The Thing

I have never seen The Thing but seeing this special effects montage is enough to ruin my sleep this evening.


Videodrome's sexy Blondie TV was an actual on-set prop. I am not sure if this is supposed to terrify me or turn me on.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

CGI never has the timing right.  Everything always looks sort of suspended, too neat, and too choreographed.  Real life is messier.  I'd take even stop-motion over CGI.  My imagination can fill in the rest and keep me interested.  CGI does all the work for me, but not in the way I want it to.

I'm not seeing nonplussed at the end of the Werner Herzog clip, though.  Unruffled, maybe?


I don't know what trailer you saw, but the VFX work I saw onscreen was extremely realistic and detailed. Your entire article is a troll-fest.

Now Trending

Houston Concert Tickets

From the Vault



Health & Beauty