5 TV Characters That Would Make Better Doctor Who Companions Than Clara

I have to be honest with you... I'm not loving Clara Oswald as a companion. At all. This pains me to admit because I was freakin' in love with her in "Asylum of the Daleks" and "The Snowmen." She was wonderful, bright, spunky, and everything we needed, but the "real" version of her from 21st century London just lacks that energy.

Part of this is the fact that they've made her very existence a plot point, which means that she's useless as a POV character. It throws the whole dynamic off as that is the very essence of the companion's purpose, to be an anchor for the viewer in The Doctor's amazing world. Without that we are left to try and see things from the point of view of a 1,100-year-old Time Lord that we'll never fully trust or understand. It's like being a figure from one of the books of the Bible where God is being an asshole.

With three episodes left in the season and the 50th anniversary later this year it looks like we're stuck with her for a while, and it's left me daydreaming about people I've seen on television that I'd rather be watching gallivant around with The Doctor. Here's the best five, and my apologies for the all-American list.

Top 10 Theories About the New Doctor Who Companion

Tina Cohen-Chang (Glee): Right about the time Glee premiered I suffered a debilitating head injury, which I hope explains why I didn't miss an episode those first two seasons before I realized that noise I heard was all the CDs in my closet screaming. Nonetheless, I always dug Tina's perky goth style and ability to be both snippy and supportive. Having re-watched a few clips of her in researching this article I find her positivity and exasperation exactly what's missing from Clara these days. Plus, it would be nice to see an Asian companion.

Audrey Horne (Twin Peaks): Granted, this may have more to do with my never-ending crush on Sherilyn Finn than anything else, but Audrey Horne was always willing to go to any ends in order to help her personal hero Dale Cooper. She was fearless and possessed of a good heart, but was prone to little wicked fits of spite that made her both a chore and a treasure. Though I'd be loathe to watch another crush on The Doctor play out, once that was out of the way you know watching her try her tricks against his enemies would be a scream.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

These characters make nonsense to me. I can't even take you seriously. Good job not choosing any good characters and it would be better just stop.  


I disagree with most of this article lol but well written nonetheless


You know my thoughts on the current season so I will forego my rant on Moffat and women...

I love these suggestions! Particularly Audrey and Xander. I'll add to the list Cordelia Chase (Buffey and Angel), Peggy Olsen (Mad Men), Bobby Singer or Castiel from Supernatural, or Penny from The Big Bang Theory.

JefWithOneF topcommenter

This comment made nonsense...


@JefWithOneF "These characters made no sense to me. I can't even take you seriously! Good job choosing crappy characters, it'd be better if you broke all 10 fingers rather than attempt to write another article."
Translation provided by Gergle

Now Trending

Houston Concert Tickets

From the Vault



Health & Beauty